A Lenten feast at Holy Trinity
Guildford Chamber Choir – Stabat Mater – 15th March 2025
The Guildford Chamber Choir is between conductors just now, but it continues to give concerts under distinguished guests. On Saturday 15th March that distinguished guest was one of the choir’s Honorary Patrons and a former conductor of the choir, Professor Steven Grahl, now director of music at Trinity College, Cambridge but with a strong Oxford career.
His choice of music, under the general title ‘Stabat Mater’ was fascinating. The concert opened with a striking setting of words from Psalm 96 by Scottish composer James MacMillan. Entitled ‘A New Song’ this was full of Scotch snaps, dramatic inflexions, an evocative organ part played by David Goode, and the choir created a tremendous impact from the very first chord.
David Goode then performed one of Bach’s Leipzig chorales in which the great tune ‘O Lamm Gottes unschuldig’ received imaginative treatment, quiet and meditative at first, then proclaimed loudly on the pedals, then breaking into an amazing chromatic passage before subsiding into a peaceful ending. In complete contrast was Palestrina’s setting of the mediaeval poem Stabat Mater, which saw the choir divide in two, although spacially not far apart. Palestrina had paid attention to the reforms initiated by the Council of Trent, insisting on greater clarity of text, so his previous elaborate contrapuntal settings were replaced by something much more chordal, and much more dramatic, but no less interesting musically. The choir gave a splendid performance, helped by a discreet organ accompaniment.
Then enter the hugely talented young cellist, Laura MacDonald, who played a Prière written during the last years of Saint-Saens’s life: although beautifully played the piece struck me as rather ordinary.
Knut Nystedt, one of Norway’s most influential composers of modern times, contributed the other setting of the Stabat Mater, in unusual vein, with the unaccompanied choir partnered by a cello, which reflects in tormented tones the feelings of the Mother of Jesus at the foot of the Cross. It is a gripping, deeply emotional piece, a brave choice, and one which came over very effectively. Laura MacDonald’s playing was without equal, and the choir sang confidently under Grahl’s expert direction.
In a similar mood was James MacMillan’s setting of that famous penitential text made famous by Gregorio Allegri in the seventeenth century, Miserere Mei. Here there were significant echoes of the chant used by Allegri, and the setting, again full of Scottish inflexions and elaborate choral writing, came over effectively. It was the one unaccompanied piece in the concert, and there was some shift in the intonation, particularly from the upper voices.
No such problems in the second piece by Palestrina, the five-part motet Parce Mihi Domine which was extremely moving, as indeed was Laura MacDonald’s thoughtful playing of two movements from one of Bach’s incomparable suites for solo cello (I shall never forget hearing Paul Tortelier playing all six of them during an English Bach Festival in the early 1970s, but Laura’s performance had almost the same impact and I was happy to tell her so).
The concert ended with Bach: his wonderful funeral motet Der Geist Hilft, a brilliant and dramatic setting of those wonderful words from St Paul’s letter to the Romans, and culminating, before the final chorale, with a magnificent double fugue, expertly executed.
A collection was taken for the Cheryl King Trust which helps to provide musical training for disadvantaged children, and the concert was attended by the Deputy Mayor of Guildford.
Shelagh Godwin